Sabrina Carpenter Turns Heads in NYC After Shocking Madonna Comparisons!

Sabrina Carpenter turned heads in New York City on Tuesday night as she stepped out to celebrate her first-ever Vogue cover. The 25-year-old pop sensation, fresh off her two Grammy wins, showcased her signature style in a daring white lace-up corset paired with a satin midi skirt featuring sheer side panels.

The “Espresso” hitmaker exuded confidence as she strutted through the snowy streets in sky-high white heels, her voluminous blonde curls cascading over a chic off-white trench coat. Surrounded by bodyguards, she radiated star power, further fueling the buzz surrounding her striking resemblance to music icon Madonna.

A Vogue Cover That Has Everyone Talking

Just hours before her night out, Vogue unveiled Sabrina as its March 2025 cover girl. Shot by the legendary Steven Meisel, the cover features the pop star rocking platinum-blonde waves and a baby blue lingerie-inspired look. Fans immediately drew comparisons to Madonna’s iconic Jean Paul Gaultier corset from her 1990 Blond Ambition World Tour and her 1991 Vogue Italia cover, also shot by Meisel.

Social media exploded with comments about the uncanny resemblance between Sabrina and the Queen of Pop. Some even joked that Madonna had “taken the substance”—a reference to Demi Moore and Margaret Qualley’s film The Substance—to create Carpenter. Others praised the young singer for embracing the aesthetic of one of pop culture’s most influential figures.

Madonna’s Playful Response

Amid the online buzz, Madonna herself took notice of the comparisons. The 66-year-old icon playfully chimed in on Sabrina’s Instagram post, commenting with eye emojis: “Is this a Valentine’s present to me?”

Sabrina, never missing a beat, responded: “It sure is!” The lighthearted exchange sent fans into a frenzy, cementing the connection between the two stars.

Honoring a Pop Legacy

Many fans saw Sabrina’s Vogue shoot as a tribute to Madonna’s legacy. One user wrote, “Seeing this Sabrina Carpenter x Steven Meisel cover makes me think about how Madonna will always be relevant in pop culture. The girls will always drink from her fountain.”

Others noted the deeper significance of the parallels between the two artists. “Sabrina referencing Madonna is so important. Two women who get criticized for embracing their sexuality, even though there’s so much more to them than that,” another fan shared.

A Career on Fire

Sabrina’s rise to superstardom has been nothing short of meteoric. After making a name for herself on Disney Channel’s Girl Meets World, she transitioned into music with her 2014 debut single Can’t Blame a Girl for Trying. Since then, she has released six studio albums, with her latest, Short n’ Sweet, dropping in August 2024.

Her recent chart-topping hits Espresso, Taste, and Please Please Please have further solidified her as a dominant force in pop music. She also gained massive exposure opening for Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour in select cities, which helped skyrocket her global recognition.

Adding to her list of accomplishments, Sabrina took home her first two Grammy Awards earlier this month, marking a defining moment in her career.

More Music on the Way

Sabrina is set to release the deluxe edition of Short n’ Sweet on Valentine’s Day, featuring several new tracks, including 15 Minutes, Bad Reviews, Couldn’t Make It Any Harder, Busy Woman, and a new version of Please Please Please featuring country music legend Dolly Parton.

She will also return to Saturday Night Live for SNL 50: The Anniversary Special and perform at the 45th Brit Awards on March 1.

With a Vogue cover, viral comparisons to Madonna, a successful music career, and major performances on the horizon, Sabrina Carpenter’s star continues to rise. Whether she’s embracing classic pop aesthetics or making her own mark on the industry, one thing is clear—she’s here to stay.