Why Disney’s ‘Tangled’ Live-Action Movie Might Be Their Biggest Fail Yet—And It’s All About Sabrina Carpenter

Disney has been on a live-action remake spree, revamping its animated classics into reimagined blockbusters. While some have succeeded, others have faltered. The next big project on their list? The live-action adaptation of Tangled—a movie fans have eagerly anticipated. But here’s the twist: It’s not the storyline or the visuals that may make this film a massive failure; it’s Sabrina Carpenter who could turn this beloved classic into Disney’s biggest misstep yet.

The Rise of Sabrina Carpenter: Is She Ready for the Role?

Sabrina Carpenter, the 24-year-old star known for her role in Girl Meets World and her growing music career, has been cast as Rapunzel in the live-action Tangled. On paper, this choice might seem like a perfect match. Carpenter has the charm, the look, and the Disney backing to pull off such a role. But, in reality, this casting decision might be the beginning of Disney’s downfall.

Carpenter has gained a dedicated following, but her acting range is still largely untested. She may be an excellent singer and dancer, but does she have the acting chops to bring Rapunzel’s complex character to life? The original animated Rapunzel, voiced by Mandy Moore, was a multi-dimensional character—brave, funny, and deeply emotional. Carpenter may have the look, but does she have the gravitas needed to pull off this iconic role?

Fans have already begun expressing their doubts on social media, with many questioning whether Carpenter is truly the best choice for such a beloved character. While her fanbase is loyal, will they be able to separate her from her previous roles, especially if she struggles to portray Rapunzel as fans expect?

Disney’s Live-Action Failures: Will Tangled Follow in Their Footsteps?

Disney’s live-action remakes have seen mixed results. While The Jungle Book and Beauty and the Beast were huge hits, others like Mulan and The Little Mermaid failed to capture the magic of their animated counterparts. There’s a growing concern that the live-action formula is running thin, and Tangled may be the one that breaks the chain.

A significant part of what made Tangled so special was its groundbreaking animation, the stunning visual aesthetics, and the unique chemistry between Rapunzel and Flynn Rider. Can these elements truly be captured in a live-action setting? Even with the most advanced technology, it’s difficult to match the wonder and charm of the original animation. The magic of Tangled was not just in its story but in the art style that gave it life.

Furthermore, casting controversies and changes to beloved characters may leave fans feeling disconnected from the live-action world. Disney seems to be walking a fine line between pleasing nostalgic fans and creating something “new.” The problem arises when the live-action adaptations become more about flashy visuals than the heart and soul of the original films. Will Tangled fall into this trap? With a star like Sabrina Carpenter, who still hasn’t proven she can hold the weight of such a role, it’s all too easy to predict a disastrous outcome.

Why Sabrina Carpenter Might Be the Key to Disney’s Biggest Fail

Carpenter’s casting is at the center of the storm. Her fanbase may not be enough to carry the film to success. Rapunzel’s character requires a lot more than just looks or a catchy Instagram presence. The live-action portrayal needs an actress with emotional depth, one who can convincingly transition from a sheltered princess to a fearless woman.

The reality is, Tangled fans already have a vision of Rapunzel that’s tied to the animated version. The idea of anyone else stepping into those shoes seems almost sacrilegious. Sabrina Carpenter’s casting may alienate many fans who are just too attached to the animated film, turning this movie into another box office disappointment for Disney.

It’s not just the casting that may lead to failure. The live-action remake of Tangled will likely bring changes to the story and characters, as seen in other adaptations. Will Disney make Rapunzel more modern or incorporate elements that feel out of place in the Tangled universe? Anything too far from the original could result in fans rejecting the film, questioning why Disney even bothered.

While some may argue that Carpenter could surprise audiences and prove herself as a worthy Rapunzel, the reality is that the odds are stacked against her. Disney has a track record of underwhelming live-action remakes, and Tangled may just be the tipping point.

As the release date looms closer, fans are waiting with bated breath—and for all the wrong reasons. Will Sabrina Carpenter be the one to break Disney’s streak of live-action failures, or will her casting signal the beginning of a long line of disappointments? Only time will tell, but for now, the future of Tangled seems more uncertain than ever.