What If Agatha Was the One Who Saved Wanda in Secret?

A Hidden Hand in the Shadows?

When the dust settled after WandaVision, the world believed that Wanda Maximoff, the Scarlet Witch, had fully embraced her destiny. She had defeated Agatha Harkness, left Westview behind, and sought refuge in solitude to understand the true depths of her chaos magic. But what if the narrative we accepted was only part of the truth? What if, in a stunning twist, Agatha had actually been the one who saved Wanda—not from others, but from herself?

Could it be that the cunning, centuries-old witch had orchestrated a secretive intervention, one that even Wanda herself was unaware of? Let’s unravel the mystery that might forever change the way we view these two powerful sorceresses.

The Spell Beneath the Surface

We all watched as Wanda seemingly took control of her fate, casting her final spell on Agatha, trapping her in the guise of the nosy neighbor Agnes. But what if that was only part of the story? The way Agatha reacted—almost as if she knew something Wanda didn’t—suggests there might be layers of magic left unexplored.

What if Agatha, in a last-ditch effort, placed an enchantment of protection on Wanda? A failsafe, hidden beneath the chaos, to shield her from the darker consequences of her growing power? Given Agatha’s vast knowledge of dark magic, it’s possible that she understood the true dangers of the Scarlet Witch’s power better than even Wanda herself.

Think about it: Wanda’s descent into the Darkhold’s magic felt strangely too smooth, too seamless. If the book was known to corrupt its users, why didn’t she spiral into darkness immediately? What if someone—or something—was holding her back? Could Agatha’s spell have secretly restrained the worst effects of the Darkhold’s influence?

A Mastermind’s Long Game?

The idea of Agatha saving Wanda in secret isn’t just a fascinating theory—it’s a move that aligns with Agatha’s character. She’s a survivor. She plays the long game. Her goal was never just to defeat Wanda, but to control and guide her power. If she couldn’t take it, why not ensure Wanda’s safety in a way that would benefit her later?

Consider the possibility that Agatha remains the only true mentor Wanda ever had. Unlike the Avengers or Doctor Strange, Agatha understood magic at its core. She didn’t fear it—she wielded it with mastery. If she had even an ounce of foresight, she would have recognized that an untrained, unstable Scarlet Witch would be a threat to reality itself. Maybe her intervention was necessary not just for Wanda’s survival, but for everyone’s.

If this theory holds, then Agatha Harkness isn’t a defeated villain—she’s a hidden force, quietly ensuring that Wanda doesn’t destroy herself. And when the time is right, perhaps she will break free from her spell, not as an enemy, but as the only ally capable of truly understanding Wanda’s power.

The Truth Yet to Be Revealed

Marvel has a knack for twisting expectations, and Agatha’s story may be far from over. With the upcoming Agatha: Darkhold Diaries, we might finally get answers. Is she still just a victim of Wanda’s spell, or has she been secretly influencing events from behind the scenes? Could her apparent defeat actually be part of a larger plan?

If there’s one thing we know for sure, it’s this: magic is never as simple as it seems. And when it comes to Wanda Maximoff, there’s always another secret waiting to be uncovered.