Is the Bengals wasting Joe Burrow’s most prime season in NFL history?

Joe Burrow is having one of the most remarkable seasons by a quarterback in NFL history. Despite this, the Cincinnati Bengals are clinging to playoff hopes, with less than an 11% chance of making it. Burrow’s exceptional performance risks being overshadowed by his team’s shortcomings, making this season one of the most wasted campaigns in recent memory.

Burrow’s Record-Breaking Statistics

Joe Burrow has delivered a historic performance this season, leading the league in completions (423), passing yards (4,641), and touchdowns (42). He joins an elite group of quarterbacks—Aaron Rodgers in 2011 and Tom Brady in 2007—as the only players in NFL history to throw for over 4,600 yards, 42 touchdowns, and fewer than 8 interceptions in a single season. Both Rodgers and Brady won the MVP in their respective years, but Burrow is unlikely to achieve the same due to the Bengals’ team struggles.

When adjusted for more pass-heavy eras like 2007 and 2011, Burrow’s numbers could balloon to 4,926 yards, 43 touchdowns, and just 8 interceptions. This statistical inflation emphasizes the magnitude of his achievements and solidifies his status as one of the league’s elite quarterbacks.

A One-Man Offense in a Flawed System

The Bengals’ offensive identity revolves almost entirely around Burrow’s arm. Cincinnati ranks 30th in rushing attempts, 23rd in rushing touchdowns, and 20th in yards per rush, highlighting their dependence on the passing game. Yet, Burrow has carried them to the sixth-best scoring offense in the NFL, a testament to his brilliance.

On the other side of the ball, the Bengals’ defense has been a liability. They rank 29th in points allowed, surrendering an average of 26 points per game. In games where Cincinnati has scored over 30 points, their record is a middling 4-4, further illustrating how defensive struggles have cost them critical wins.

Heartbreaking close losses to teams like Baltimore (two losses by a combined 4 points), Pittsburgh (6 points), and Kansas City (1 point) showcase how one or two defensive stops could have turned their season around. Despite Burrow’s heroics, the Bengals sit on the playoff bubble, needing a win and outside help to extend their season.

Cap Space Challenges Loom Ahead

Even if the Bengals achieve a miraculous playoff berth, they face significant salary cap challenges heading into 2025. Joe Burrow’s cap hit will jump from $29.7 million to a staggering $46.25 million, forcing the team to make tough financial decisions.

Tee Higgins, currently on a $21.8 million franchise tag, may be the odd man out, as the Bengals must prioritize extending star wideout Ja’Marr Chase, who is entering the fifth year of his rookie deal. Together, Burrow, Chase, and Higgins could account for nearly a third of the team’s salary cap, making it unlikely the Bengals can retain all three.

To offset these costs, Cincinnati must draft wisely, particularly on defense. Trey Hendrickson, responsible for 14 of the team’s 32 sacks, has been a bright spot, but more depth is needed. The team could save $9.6 million by replacing Sam Hubbard through the draft, allowing them to address other defensive weaknesses while staying under the cap.

Will Burrow’s season be remembered?

Joe Burrow’s 2024 season is undeniably one for the record books. His remarkable statistics and ability to elevate a one-dimensional offense highlight his elite status in the NFL. Yet, without team success to complement his efforts, this season risks being remembered as one of the most wasted in league history.

The Bengals’ defensive shortcomings and looming salary cap issues leave many questions for the offseason. Whether they can draft the right talent and make smart financial decisions will determine if Burrow’s prime years are squandered or maximized.

Ultimately, Burrow’s brilliance has proven his worth as a franchise quarterback, and his performance deserves to be celebrated. The Bengals must now rise to his level if they hope to ensure his legacy is not one of wasted potential but of championship triumphs.