What REALLY Happened Between Charlie Puth and Shawn Mendes? We Investigate!

For years, Charlie Puth and Shawn Mendes have been two of the most talked-about names in the music industry. Both incredibly talented, both heartthrobs in their own right, and both with an undeniable ability to create chart-topping hits. But rumors have swirled for quite some time about their complicated relationship—is it a friendly rivalry, a professional falling out, or something even deeper? The internet is buzzing with theories, and we decided to dig in.

The Tension That Started It All

It wasn’t always this way. Charlie Puth and Shawn Mendes started off as mutual admirers. In the early days of their careers, they supported each other in interviews, praised each other’s music, and even hinted at potential collaborations. But then, something changed.

The first signs of tension appeared when Charlie Puth made an unexpected comment about Mendes during an Instagram Live session. He cryptically said, “You guys don’t even know the half of it,” when asked about their relationship. Fans immediately latched onto the statement, speculating whether something had gone wrong behind closed doors.

Adding fuel to the fire, in an interview with a major music magazine, Shawn Mendes was asked about Charlie. His response? A long pause, followed by a simple, “He’s talented.” It wasn’t much, but in the world of pop music—where stars go out of their way to praise each other—this lack of enthusiasm spoke volumes.

A Collab That Never Happened?

One of the biggest mysteries surrounding Charlie Puth and Shawn Mendes is the song that was supposed to happen but never did. Back in 2018, Charlie hinted in a tweet that he was working on something “crazy” with a major artist. Soon after, fans noticed Shawn Mendes liking posts about a possible collaboration with Charlie.

But the track never surfaced.

When asked about it, both artists dodged the question. Charlie Puth simply laughed and changed the subject, while Shawn Mendes vaguely said, “It just didn’t come together.” But insiders in the music industry have whispered that creative differences—and possibly personal ones—led to the entire project being scrapped.

The Haunting Lyrics & Cryptic Messages

As if the drama wasn’t enough, Charlie Puth and Shawn Mendes have both released songs that fans believe contain hidden messages about their fallout. Take Charlie’s track Attention, for example. Some believe the lyrics, “You just want attention, you don’t want my heart,” could be a subtle dig at a certain someone who allegedly used him for clout.

On the other hand, Shawn Mendes has also thrown some subtle shade in his music. In his song Monster, which he recorded with Justin Bieber, there are lines about being put on a pedestal and then being torn down. Many believe these lyrics could be referencing Charlie Puth, who has been vocal about the pressures of fame and the industry’s fickleness.

But it doesn’t stop there.

Eagle-eyed fans have also noticed strange coincidences in their social media activity. Charlie Puth has been caught liking and unliking tweets about Mendes, while Shawn has mysteriously removed certain posts from his Instagram stories that referenced Charlie. Coincidence? Or something more?

So, Where Do They Stand Now?

While neither Charlie Puth nor Shawn Mendes have outright confirmed or denied a feud, their actions continue to keep fans guessing. Some believe they’ve quietly moved past whatever differences they had, while others are convinced the tension still lingers beneath the surface.

Will they ever address the rumors head-on? Will we finally get the collaboration that fans have been dying for? Or will this remain one of the music industry’s greatest unsolved mysteries?

One thing is certain: whether friends or frenemies, these two continue to keep the world talking.