The Yankees’ $218 Million Free Agent Signing Called a ‘Nightmare’ Contract
The New York Yankees made a significant offseason move by signing Max Fried, a dominant left-handed pitcher from the Atlanta Braves, to an eight-year, $218 million contract. This signing aimed to bolster the Yankees’ rotation, especially after their rival, the New York Mets, secured Juan Soto. However, this high-profile deal has drawn criticism, with some analysts labeling it a potential “nightmare” contract.
Max Fried’s Contract and Its Criticism
Max Fried has proven himself as a top-tier pitcher in the National League, but concerns are emerging about the long-term value of his massive contract. According to Bleacher Report’s Zachary D. Rymer, projections like ZiPS estimate Fried’s performance over the next eight years to be worth only $120 million, far below the Yankees’ investment.
Rymer pointed out that Fried carries notable injury risks, having undergone Tommy John surgery earlier in his career and suffering from forearm strains in 2023 and 2024. Additionally, Fried’s whiff rate and barrel rate declined between 2023 and 2024, indicating a dip in his effectiveness, even on his renowned curveball.
Pressure to Deliver a World Series Win
For the Yankees, the clock is ticking. Analysts suggest that for Fried’s contract to be deemed successful, the Yankees must secure a World Series title within the next two years. If they fail, the back half of the deal could weigh heavily on the team’s financial and competitive future.
Despite these concerns, Fried remains optimistic. Reflecting on his decision to join the Yankees, Fried shared his excitement about wearing the iconic pinstripes and embracing the high expectations that come with being a Yankee.
“You just know the standard that the Yankees hold, and putting on the pinstripes comes with a certain responsibility,” Fried said.
Fried’s 2024 Performance and Future Expectations
In 2024, Fried had a solid season with the Braves, posting an 11-10 record and a 3.25 ERA in 29 starts. These stats showcase his capability, but critics argue that maintaining such performance for the entirety of his eight-year deal will be a challenge.
The Yankees’ decision to prioritize pitching over big bats, following the loss of Juan Soto to the Mets, underscores their belief in Fried’s potential to elevate their rotation. However, the hefty contract ensures that every pitch Fried throws will be scrutinized, with fans and analysts alike eager to see if the gamble pays off.
Is the Investment Worth It?
The Yankees’ bet on Max Fried demonstrates their commitment to strengthening their roster, but it comes with inherent risks. Will Fried’s presence in the rotation lead to a long-awaited championship? Or will this deal become another cautionary tale of overspending in free agency?
As the 2025 season approaches, all eyes will be on Max Fried to prove his worth and help the Yankees reclaim their dominance.
